What to expect: With Victorian antiques at each turn, this Colonial-style hotel is like a turn-of-the-century museum and guest house. Built on 6 acres of gardens, the Madison provides a refreshing escape from the rush of Northern New Jersey. The homey lobby hosts a piano and sunken lounge with wood-burning fireplace and Tiffany mantle. The hotel is popular with corporate groups and is a favorite spot for private parties.

Amenity highlights: The Madison maintains several meeting and event facilities, including a conservatory with glass ceiling and a grand ballroom with Victorian paneling and crystal-and-gold antique Baccarat chandeliers. The indoor splash pool and spa tub have floor-to-ceiling windows with a view of the hotel lawn, while the fitness room has cardio equipment and free weights. The hotel offers complimentary shuttle service within a 5-mile area, based on availability.

Insider tip: The Midtown Direct train departs from Convent Station, just across the street from the hotel. From there, New York City's Penn Station is an approximately 45-minute ride.